Exploring Lost Spirits and Legends at Hotel Saint Nicholas in Shenanigans In the Shadows Episode Three
- Gail Conners
- Dec 6, 2025
- 2 min read
Updated: Dec 19, 2025
The latest episode of the Shenanigans In the Shadows podcast has just landed, and it promises to captivate anyone interested in the paranormal. Episode three, titled Lost Spirits and Found Legends, takes listeners on a journey through the haunted history of the Hotel Saint Nicholas in Cripple Creek, Colorado. Hosts Carly and Gail share personal experiences and stories from their paranormal investigations, offering a unique glimpse into the mysterious world of spirits and legends tied to this historic location.

The Haunted History of Hotel Saint Nicholas
Hotel Saint Nicholas stands as a landmark in Cripple Creek, a town rich with mining history and ghost stories. Built in the late 19th century, the hotel has witnessed decades of change, tragedy, and mystery. Over the years, it has earned a reputation as one of Colorado’s most haunted locations.
In the podcast, Carly and Gail recount how the hotel’s past is filled with tales of miners, travelers, and residents who have left behind more than just memories. One spirit in particular, named Roy, stands out. Roy is said to be a friendly spirit who has become a part of the local community’s stories and efforts to honor the hotel’s haunted legacy.
The Spirit Named Roy and Community Efforts
One of the most compelling parts of the episode is the story of Roy, a spirit who has become a symbol of the hotel’s haunted history.
Carly and Gail talk about how engaging with the community enriches the paranormal experience. It goes beyond just ghost hunting to include connecting with history and honoring those who preceded us. The episode emphasizes that paying tribute to spirits like Roy helps preserve local legends and nurtures a sense of shared heritage.
Future Plans and New Features
Listeners are treated to a special premiere in this episode: a new theme song called Shenanigans Shakedown! Written and performed by Carly Kryzer, Zach Barrett, and Erica Burton, the song adds fresh energy to the podcast.
Looking ahead, Carly and Gail share plans for more events and episodes that will continue to explore haunted locations, paranormal tools, and community stories. They invite listeners to join them on this journey, promising more engaging content and deeper dives into the shadows.
The third episode of Shenanigans In the Shadows offers more than ghost stories. It provides a respectful, community-focused look at the paranormal world through the lens of the Hotel Saint Nicholas. Whether you are a skeptic or a believer, the blend of history, personal experience, and cultural insight makes this episode a must-listen.



Comments